Levée des résolutions de mesures de précaution

Résolution No. 80/22( LEVAGE )
MC 29-16 - Margarita Marín Yan et al. , Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of David Mendoza Marín, Margarita Marín Yan, and Alfredo Elías Marín Bustos, as well as Carola Marín, Tomás Mendoza, and their respective families, in Mexico. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during the implementation and the change in circumstances that led to the granting, such as having found the whereabouts of the disappeared persons, whose corpses were found. Similarly, the Commission identifies the lack of specific facts that would be sufficient to identify, at present, an imminent risk to the detriment of the remaining beneficiaries. Following the State's request to have the measures lifted, the IACHR requested comments from the representatives, who have provided comments aimed at the friendly settlement process, which it is not appropriate to evaluate through the precautionary measures mechanism. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 79/22( LEVAGE )
MC 204-14, 489-15, 156-17, 1048-20 - John Winfield and three others , United States

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of John Winfield, Alfredo Rolando Prieto, William Charles Morva, and Lisa Montgomery in the United States. At the time of the decision, the Commission observes that the beneficiaries have been executed despite the precautionary measures being in force and having requested that the State refrain from applying the death penalty while the Commission analyzed the related petitions. In its assessment, the IACHR also observed that the execution of sentences giving rise to the death penalty implies both a significant change in the factual circumstances that motivated the granting of precautionary measures, as well as a failure to implement them. The IACHR condemns the application of the death penalty to persons benefiting from precautionary measures. Notwithstanding the lifting of the precautionary measures, the Commission continues with the analysis of the related petitions, as appropriate.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 78/22( LEVAGE )
MC 384-02, 348-06, 177-14, 204-07, 736-17, 250-17 - Roberto Moreno Ramos and five other persons , United States

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Roberto Moreno Ramos, Rubén Ramírez Cárdenas, Orlando Cordia Hall, Russell Bucklew, Charles Warner, and Lezmond C. Mitchell in the United States. At the time of taking the decision, the Commission notes that the beneficiaries have been executed even though the precautionary measures granted in their favor were in force and the IACHR issued Merits Reports whereby the responsibility of the State was determined, as appropriate. In its assessment, the IACHR also observed that the execution of sentences giving rise to the death penalty implies both a significant change in the factual circumstances that motivated the granting of precautionary measures, as well as a failure to implement them. The IACHR condemns the application of the death penalty to beneficiaries of precautionary measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 75/22( LEVAGE )
MC 29-15 - Nazira María Ugalde Alfaro, Peru

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) has decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Nazira María Ugalde Alfaro. At the time of taking the decision, the Commission assessed the measures that the State adopted internally and identified a factual change in the circumstances regarding Ms. Ugalde. In that regard, the Commission considered that, at present, it is not possible to identify an imminent risk situation within the meaning of Article 25 of the Rules of Procedure. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 69/22( LEVAGE )
MC 452-13 - Lauro Baumea Mora et al. , Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to partially lift these precautionary measures granted in favor of (1) Lauro Baumea Mora, (2) Miguel Ángel Cota Tórtola, (3) Aurelia Butimenia, (4) Librado Valenzuela Valencia, (5) Esteban Cecilio Valenzuela Buitimea, (6) Arturo Matas Gonzáles, (7) Gilberto Gálvez Palma, and (8) Gregorio Valdez Molina, members of the Yaqui People. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during the implementation, as well as the absence of recent threatening events, along with the will of Ms. Aurelia Buitimea. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements regarding these persons, the IACHR decided to lift the instant measures.

On the other hand, the IACHR decided to maintain the precautionary measures in favor of Mario Luna and his family. Consequently, the Commission requested as follows:

  1. to the representatives, to present updated information on the risk faced by Mr. Mario Luna and his family;
  2. to the State, to carry out an updated risk assessment and adopt the appropriate and effective protection measures determined by its authorities in the matter;
  3. to both parties, to collaborate in the concerted actions that may be necessary for the proper implementation of the precautionary measures.
Upon receiving the information from the parties and having forwarded the corresponding information, the Commission will analyze whether the beneficiaries' situation persists.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 67/22( LEVAGE )
MC 400-15 - O.Y.L. and 14 other persons , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the 15 identified members of the Governing Board of the Alto Mira and Frontera Community Council (CCAMF, by its acronym in Spanish). At the time of taking the decision to lift the precautionary measures, the Commission assessed the measures implemented by the State reported over time. Considering that the State requested the lifting of these precautionary measures, the Commission forwarded the request to the representatives, who did not respond. The last communication from the representatives is from 2018. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 66/22( LEVAGE )
MC 197-10 - 135 inhabitants of San Juan Copala regarding Mexico, Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of 135 inhabitants of San Juan Copala in Mexico. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during the implementation, the observations of the representatives, and the fact that the initial situation presenting a risk no longer exists. Following the requests made by the State to have the measures lifted and the information provided by the representatives, including the agreement of one party, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 63/22( LEVAGE )
MC 1014-17 - Indigenous girl U. V. O. and family , Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the indigenous girl U. V. O. and her family, in Mexico. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during the implementation, as well as the lack of updated information from representatives. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements and considering the State's request to lift the precautionary measures, the IACHR decided to lift them.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 62/22( LEVAGE )
MC 114-06 - Mayan Community-Sitio “El Rosario-Naranjo” , Guatemala

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) has decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the Sitio "El Rosario-Naranjo" in Guatemala Mayan Community. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the responses issued by the State and the observations submitted by the representatives. Following the request to lift reiterated by the State over time, and the response submitted by the representatives, the IACHR has decided to lift these precautionary measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 56/22( LEVAGE )
MC 968-20 - Mariano Valle Peters , Nicaragua

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) has decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Mr. Mariano Valle Peters, in Nicaragua. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the change in circumstances and the request to have the measures lifted made by the representatives themselves. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures under the terms of Article 25 of its Rules of Procedure.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 54/22( LEVAGE )
MC 262-02, 465-11, 470-11, 357-11 - Abu-Ali Abdur' Rahman and three others , United States

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Abu-Ali Abdur' Rahman, Virgilio Maldonado Rodríguez, Iván Teleguz, and Héctor Rolando Medina in the United States. Having analyzed the information available, the IACHR considered that there are no sufficient elements to continue identifying compliance with the requirements of Article 25 of the Rules of Procedure. In its assessment, the IACHR observed that commutations of the death penalty represent a significant change in the factual circumstances that motivated the granting of precautionary measures at the time.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 51/22( LEVAGE )
MC 302-15 - Adolescents deprived of their liberty at the Center for Socio-Educational Attention of Adolescents (CASA) Cedro, Brazil

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) has decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the adolescents deprived of liberty at the Center for Socio-Educational Attention of Adolescents (CASA) Cedro in Brazil. At the time of making this decision, the Commission considered the change in circumstances, the suspension of activities since March 10, 2021, and the fact that there are no longer adolescents deprived of their liberty at the Center. Currently, since the procedural requirements are no longer being met, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 45/22( LEVAGE )
MC 306-06 - Jorge Luís García Pérez Antúnez, Cuba

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Jorge Luís García Pérez Antúnez, in Cuba. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the change in the situation of the beneficiary, who currently resides in the United States of America. After failing to identify compliance with the regulatory requirements, the IACHR decided to lift these measures, while regretting the lack of information from the Cuban State.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 44/22( LEVAGE )
MC 789-04, 1026-04, 471-11 (parcial/partial) - Gregory Thompson and other persons , United States

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Gregory Thompson, Richard Michael Rossi, German Sinnistera, Robert L. Bolden, and Arboleda Ortiz in the United States. At the time of taking the decision, the Commission notes that the beneficiaries have died, or their sentences have been commuted. The Commission assessed the actions taken by the State in implementing the measures at hand and the information provided by the representatives. In analyzing the available information, the IACHR considered that there are no sufficient elements to continue identifying compliance with the procedural requirements. In its assessment, the IACHR observed that the death of the beneficiaries implies a significant change in the factual circumstances that led to the granting of the precautionary measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 40/22( LEVAGE )
MC 349-20 - Jorge Ernesto López Zea , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Mr. Jorge Ernesto López Zea, in Colombia. At the time of making this decision, the Commission observes that the beneficiary's situation has changed significantly as he is no longer deprived of his liberty. After evaluating the information received by the parties in the framework of analyzing whether the precautionary measures should remain in force, the IACHR considered that they should be lifted in accordance with the terms of Article 25 of its Rules of Procedure.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 39/22( LEVAGE )
MC 134-00 - Regional Corporation for the Defense of Human Rights (CREDHOS) , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the directors and officials of the Regional Corporation for the Defense of Human Rights (CREDHOS). At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during implementation as well as the observations of the beneficiaries' representation. Following the State's requests to have the measures lifted, the IACHR requested information from the representation, who did not provide a response. Upon not identifying compliance with the regulatory requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 36/22( LEVAGE )
MC 382-21 - Ovidio Jesús Poggioli Pérez , Venezuela

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Ovidio Jesús Poggioli Pérez, in Venezuela. At the time of making the decision, the Commission considered that the beneficiary had been released and observed that his situation substantially changed. The IACHR decided to lift these measures and considered the lack of response from the State as serious in regard to the specific implementation of measures adopted while these measures were in place.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 35/22( LEVAGE )
MC 134-07 - Alba Gabriela Cruz Ramos, Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decided to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Alba Gabriela Cruz Ramos, in Mexico. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during the implementation and the repeated request to have the measures lifted, as well as the lack of information from the beneficiary. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 31/22( LEVAGE )
MC 886-21 - Sebastián Quiñónez Echavarría , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Mr. Sebastián Quiñónez Echavarría in Colombia. At the time of making the decision, the Commission notes that the fate and whereabouts of the beneficiary have been identified. In this regard, since his whereabouts had been determined, the IACHR regretted the death of Sebastián Quiñónez Echavarría and, by virtue of the change in circumstances, it considered that the measures had been rendered moot, given that the requirements of Article 25 of the Rules of Procedure were not fulfilled.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 29/22( LEVAGE )
MC 286-19 - C.F.M.T. , Dominican Republic

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures granted to C.F.M.T. while he was deprived of his liberty in the Dominican Republic. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during implementation as well as the observations of the beneficiary's representatives. Following the State's request to have the measures lifted, the IACHR requested information from the representatives, who confirmed that C.F.M.T. had been released. Upon not finding compliance with the procedural requirements and in view of the change in circumstances that led to the granting of the precautionary measures, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 28/22( LEVAGE )
MC 331-22 - Clarence Wayne Dixon , United States

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Mr. Clarence Wayne Dixon in the United States of America. At the time of making the decision, the Commission observes that the death sentence imposed on Mr. Clarence Wayne Dixon was carried out. Having analyzed the available information, the IACHR considered that there are no sufficient elements to continue identifying compliance with the procedural requirements. In its assessment, the IACHR observed that carrying out the death penalty represents a significant change in the factual circumstances that motivated the granting of the precautionary measures. Consequently, the IACHR has decided to lift these precautionary measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 20/22( LEVAGE )
MC 404-10 - Members of the Qom Navogoh Indigenous Community “La Primavera” , Argentina

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the members of the Qom Navogoh indigenous community "La Primavera," in the Formosa Province, Argentina. At the time of making the decision, the Commission evaluated the actions that the State took during implementation, as well as the observations from the beneficiaries' representatives. Following the State's request to lift, the IACHR requested the representatives' observations. Upon assessing the circumstantial changes and as, based on the information available, it was not possible to determine that the procedural requirements were fulfilled, the IACHR has decided to lift the present measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 19/22( LEVAGE )
MC 364-17 - G.Y.G.R. , Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of the adolescent G.Y.G.R. in Mexico. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the change of circumstances, as well as the measures adopted by the State during the implementation. It was determined that Mr. González is the father of G.Y.G.R. and the precautionary measure of 2011 that prevented their relationship was lifted. Similarly, it was observed that the process towards rebuilding the relationship continues to progress with the aid of specialists and the assessments of judicial authorities. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 18/22( LEVAGE )
MC 21-11 - Blanca Velázquez Díaz et al., Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Blanca Velázquez Díaz et al., in Mexico. At the time of making the decision, the Commission evaluated the actions taken by the State during implementation as well as the observations furnished by the representatives. Following the State's request to have the measures lifted, the IACHR repeatedly requested observations from the representatives, who submitted their last response in 2015. To date, no response has been received for the communications sent in 2017, 2019, and 2022. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures. The IACHR also assessed that, according to public information, Ms. Blanca Velázquez Díaz died of cancer in 2021.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 16/22( LEVAGE )
MC 52-16 - María Dolores López Godoy, Nelly Lizeth Martínez Martínez, and family, Honduras

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of María Dolores López Godoy, Nelly Lizeth Martínez Martínez, and family. In making its decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during implementation. Following the requests to have the measures lifted made by the State, the IACHR repeatedly requested observations from the representatives, who have not presented information since the precautionary measures were granted. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 15/22( LEVAGE )
MC 209-07 - Carlos Mario Gómez Gómez, Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Carlos Mario Gómez Gómez, in Colombia. At the time of making the decision, the Commission notes that the State has requested that this matter be lifted. The Commission assessed the actions taken by the State to implement these measures and the information provided by the representatives. Having analyzed the information available, the IACHR considered that there are no sufficient elements to continue identifying compliance with the procedural requirements. In its assessment, the IACHR observed that there is no dispute between the parties that Mr. Gómez has recovered his freedom, so the factual circumstances that called for the granting of the precautionary measures have changed significantly.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 14/22( LEVAGE )
MC 72-11 - Leonel Casco Gutiérrez, Honduras

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift the precautionary measures in favor of Lionel Casco Gutiérrez. In making the decision, the Commission evaluated the actions taken by the State during implementation as well as the observations of the representatives. Following the request to lift the measures made by the State, the IACHR repeatedly requested observations from the representatives, who last responded in 2017 and failed to respond to the requests for information made in 2018, 2020, and 2022. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR has decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 13/22( LEVAGE )
MC 368-10 - María Tirsa Paz et al. , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of María Tirsa Paz et al. in Colombia. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State within the framework of these measures, as well as the request made by the Stated to lift the measures, along with the observations from the representatives. The Commission understands that, based on the information available, at present, the situation does not meet the requirements of Article 25 of the Rules of Procedure.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 6/22( LEVAGE )
MC 254-10 - Leiderman Ortiz Berrio , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Leiderman Ortiz Berrio in Colombia. At the time of making the decision, the Commission evaluated the actions taken by the State during implementation as well as the observations of the beneficiary' representation. Upon having forwarded several times information between the parties, the representation stopped providing information since 2015. Following the State's request to have the measures lifted in 2021, the representation responded and agreed with the State, considering that the beneficiary died for reasons related to COVID-19. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 4/22( LEVAGE )
MC 356-16 - Child A.R. , Argentina

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of child A.R. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions adopted by the State during implementation, as well as the observations from the beneficiary's representation. The Commission understands that the factual circumstances that called for the granting of the precautionary measures have changed significantly. Currently, there are domestic court decisions in place which stay the international return order and make it conditional on the welfare of child A.R. Similarly, it is not a matter of dispute that child A.R. receives specialized medical care. Upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 3/22( LEVAGE )
MC 338-13 - Lorenzo Santos Torres and his family , Mexico

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift these precautionary measures in favor of Lorenzo Santos Torres and his family, in Mexico. In making the decision, the Commission assessed the measures implemented by the State throughout the time the precautionary measures have been in force, as well as the observations furnished by the beneficiaries' representation. Following the State's repeated request to have the measures lifted, the IACHR requested observations from the representation. The representation did not submit their response, their last communication being in August 2021. Upon assessing the significant change in the factual circumstances given the measures adopted by the State, the IACHR decided to lift these measures under the terms of Article 25 of its Rules of Procedure.

lire la résolution

Résolution No. 2/22( LEVAGE )
MC 243-10 - Sigifredo Espinosa Pérez and his family , Colombia

The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) decides to lift the precautionary measures in favor of Sigifredo Espinosa Pérez and his family in Colombia. At the time of making the decision, the Commission assessed the actions taken by the State during implementation as well as the observations of the beneficiaries' representation. Following the several requests to have the measures lifted made by the State between 2010 and 2021, the responses from the representation received until 2020, as well as the lack of response from the representation to the request for information made in 2021 in the procedure, and upon not identifying compliance with the procedural requirements, the IACHR decided to lift these measures.

lire la résolution