OAS :: IACHR :: Rapporteurship on the Rights of Persons Deprived of Liberty

Deprived of Liberty

Reports on Petitions and Cases

Admissibility
Inadmissibility
Merits
Friendly Settlement
Cases sent to the I/A Court
Archive

Admissibility Report No. 69/11, Petition 10.949 - Magda Mateo Bruno (Peru), March 31, 2011.
Admissibility Report No. 14/11, Petition 1347-07 - Orlando Edgardo Olivares Muñoz (Venezuela), March 23, 2011.
Admissibility Report No. 9/11, Petition 1205/07 - Orlando Abel Obando Reyes y otros (Nicaragua), March 22, 2011.
Admissibility Report No. 179/10, Petition 979/98 - Wilfredo Mas Trigoso (Peru), December 9, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 155/10, Petitions 755/04 - Jaime Humberto Díaz Alva; 802-04 - Rubén Galván Borja; 869-04 - Eduardo Eliud Espinoza Narcizo y 996-04 - Vladimir Carlos Villanueva (Peru), November 1, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 153/10, Petition 43/05 - Haroon Khan (Trinidad and Tobago), November 1, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 142/10, Case 11.513 - María Zambrano (Ecuador), November 1, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 141/10, Petition 247/07 - Luis Eduardo Guachalá Chimbó (Ecuador), November 1, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 108/10, Petitions 744/08, Orestes Auberto Urriola Gonzáles; 614/00, Cecilia Rosana Núñez Chipana y 1.300/04 - Cirpiano Sabino Campos Hinostroza (Peru), August 26, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 78/10, Petitions 621/03 - Ramón Campos Esparza y 1.378/04 - Roberto Antonio Olórtegui Trinidad (Peru), July 12, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 41/10, Petition No. 999/06 – Adao Pereira de Souza and Clotilde de Souza Rocha (Brazil), March 17, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 10/10, Petition No. 214-08 - Koempai et al (Suriname), March 16, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 6/10, Petition No. 262/05 – Jose do Egito Romao Dias (Brazil), March 15, 2010.
Admissibility Report N° 3/10, Petition No. 12.088 – Segundo Norberto Contreras Contreras (Ecuador), March 15, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 69/10, Petition No. 11.444 – Amparo Constante Merizalde (Ecuador), July 12, 2010.
Admissibility Report Nº 72/10, Petition No. 161/01 – Irineo Marinez Torres and Candelario Martinez Damian (Mexico), July 12, 2010.
Admissibility Report Nº 73/10, Petition No. 980/04 – Fernando rodriguez Gonzalez et all (Mexico), July 12, 2004.
Admissibility Report N° 9/10, Petition No. 703/98 and others – Luis Enrique Lopez Medrano et all (Peru), March 16, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 65/10, Petition No. 827/98 – Rutaldo Alejo Saavedra and Raul Andres Arias (Peru), June 21, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 66/10, Petition No. 737/01 – Guillermo Ernesto Yapias Camavilca (Peru), June 21, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 74/10, Petition No. 574/98, 106/03, 766/04 and 863/04 – Luis A. Miranda Moscol, Jorge E. Olivares del Carpio, Aurelio Aquino Pari y Boris Mijail Taype Castillo (Peru), July 12, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 77/10, Petition No. 12.154 – Luis Alberto Vega Pasquillo (Peru), July 12, 2010.
Admissibility Report No. 136/09, Petition No. 321/05 – Maria Ines Chinchilla (Guatemala), November 13, 2009.
Admissibility Report Nº 137/09, Petition No. 981/05 – Reshi Bisson and Foster Serrette (Trinidad and Tonago), November 13, 2009.
Admissibility Report N° 23/09, Petition No. 23/09 – Raul Jose Diaz Pena (Venezuela), March 20, 2009.
Admissibility Report No. 26/08, Petition No. 270/02 – Cesar Alberto Mendoza et al (Argentina), March 14, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 68/08, Petition No. 231/98 – Ernesto Travisi (Argentina), October 16, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 69/08, Petition No. 681/00 – Guillermo Patricio Lynn (Argentina), October 16, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 8/08, Case No. 11.426 – Marcela Alejandra Porco (Bolivia), March 4, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 84/08, Petition No. 40/03 – Blas Valencia Campos et al (Bolivia), October 30, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 41/08, Petition No. 478/07 – Persons Deprived of Liberty at the Provisional Detention Center of Guaruja, Sao Paulo (Brazil), July 23, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 74/08, Petition No. 4524/02 – Juan Vergara Reyes (Chile), October 17, 2008.
Admissibility Report N° 78/08, Petition No. 785/05 – Rafael Arturo Pacheco Teruel (Honduras), October 17, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 16/08, Caso No. 12.359 – Cristina Aguayo Ortiz et al (Paraguay), March 6, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 86/08, Petition No. 4/03 – Juan Francisco Arrom Suhurt et al (Paraguay), October 30, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 27/08, Case No. 11.769-A – Jesus Monica Feria Tinta (Peru), March 14, 2008.
Admissibility Report No. 28/08, Petition No. 1241/05 – Johnny Omar Lopez Quezada (Peru), May 19, 2008.
Admissibility Report N° 56/07, Petition No. 399/99 – Mariano Gerpe (Argentina), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 18/07, Petition No. 12.479 – Jose Honorato et al (Brazil), March 3, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 36/07, Petition No. 1113/06 – Persons deprived of liberty in the cells at the 76th Police Precinct in Niteroi, Rio de Janeiro (Brazil), July 17, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 40/07, Petition No. 665/05 – Alan Felipe Da Silva et al (Brazil), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 41/07, Petition No. 998/05 – Lanzinho Brambilla Da Silva (Brazil), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 44/07, Petition No. 538/01 – Jorge Sotomayor Corrales (Chile), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 48/07, Petition No. 261/03 – Karina Montenegro et al (Ecuador), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 6/07, Petition No. 4657/02 – Cesar Centeno Rosales et al (Guatemala), February 27, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 49/07, Petition No. 613/03 – Luis Rey Garcia Villagran (Mexico), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 54/07, Petition No. 4614/02 – Wilmer Antonio Gonzalez Rojas (Nicaragua), July 24, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 42/07, Petition No. 156/05 – Luis Williams Pollo Rivera (Peru), July 23, 2007.
Admissibility Report N° 58/07, Petition No. 1101/05 – Gabriel Orlando Vera Navarrete (Peru), July 25, 2007.
Admissibility Report No. 81-06, Petition 394/02 – Persons Deprived of Liberty at Urso Branco Prision, Rondonia (Brazil), October 21, 2006.
Admissibility Report No. 65/06, Petition 81-06 – Jimmy Charles (Haiti), July 20, 2006.
Admissibility Report No. 48/06 (Available in Spanish), Petition No. 12.174 – Israel Gerardo Paredes Costa (Dominican Republic), March 15, 2006. (Available only is Spanish)
Admissibility Report No. 39/06, Petition 73/03 – Carlos Rafael Alfonso Martinez (Venezuela), March 15, 2006.
Admissibility Report No. 70/05, Petition 1231/04 – Inmates of the Mendoza Penitentiary (Argentina), October 13, 2005.
Admissibility Report No. 4/04, Petition 12.324 – Ruben Luis Godoy (Argentina), February 24, 2004.
Admissibility Report No. 50/04, Petition 12.056 – Gabriel Oscar Jenkins (Argentina), October 13, 2004.
Admissibility Report No. 12/04, Petition 4390/02 – Inmates of Challapalca Prison (Peru), February 27, 2004.
Admissibility Report No. 51/03, Petition 11.819 – Christias Daniel Dominguez Domenichetti (Argentina), October 24, 2003.
Admissibility Report No. 80/03, Petition 12.287 – Cruz Davila Mondragon (Mexico), October 22, 2003.
Admissibility Report 85/03, Petition 12.165 – Monsi Lilia Velarde Retamoso (Peru), October 22, 2003.
Admissibility Report No. 40/02, Petition 12.167 – Arguelles et al. (Argentina), October 9, 2002.
Admissibility Report No. 12/02, Petition 12.090 – Jesus Enrique Valderrama Perea (Ecuador), February 27, 2002.
Admissibility Report No. 71/99, Case No. 11.656 – Marta Lucia Alvarez Giraldo (Colombia), May 4, 1999.

Inadmissibility Report No. 106/09, Petition No. 12.323 – Jorge Portilla Ponce (Ecuador), October 31, 2009.
Inadmissibility Report No. 118/09, Petition No. 397-04 – Nelson Aparecido Trindade (Brasil), November 12, 2009.
Inadmissibility Report No. 119/09, Petition No. 398-04 – Edson Prado (Brasil), November 12, 2009.
Inadmisibility Report N° 26/07, Petition No. 12.399 – David Austin Smmith (Bahamas), March 9, 2007.
Inadmissibility Report No. 32/99, Petition No. 11.048 – Victor Alfredo Polay Campos (Peru), March 10, 2000. (Available only in Spanish).
Inadmissibility Report Nº 96/98, Petition No. 11.827 – Peter Blaine (Jamaica), December 17, 1998.
Inadmissibility Report Nº 97/98, Petition No. 97/98 – Neville Lewis (Jamaica), December 17, 1998.

Report on the Merits Nº 28/09, Case No. 12.269 – Dexter Lendore (Trinidad and Tobago), March 20, 2009.
Report on the Merits No. 84/09, Case No. 12.525 – Nelson Iván Serrano Sáenz (Ecuador), August 6, 2009.
Report on the Merits No. 86/09, Case No. 12.553 – Jorge, José and Dante Peirano Basso Eastern (Uruguay), August 6, 2009.
Report on the Merits No. 117/09, Case No. 12.228 – Alfonso Martin del Campo Dodd (Mexico), November 19, 2009.
Report on the Merits No. 35/08, Case No. 12.019 – Antonio Ferreira Braga (Brazil), July 18, 2008.
Report on the Merits N° 78/07, Case No. 12.265 – Chad Roger Goodman(Commonwealth of the Bahamas), October 15, 2007.
Report on the Merits No. 81/07, Case No. 12.504 – Daniel and Kornel Vaux (Guyana), October 15, 2007.
Report on the Merits No. 67/06, Case No. 12.476 – Oscar Elías Biscet Et Al. (Cuba), October 21, 2006.
Report on the Merits No. 41/04, Case No. 12.417 – Whitley Myrie (Jamaica), October 12, 2004.
Report on the Merits No. 40/03, Case No. 10.301 – 42nd Police District Parque São Lucas São Paulo (Brazil), October 8, 2003.
Report on the Merits No. 55/02, Petition No. 11.765 – Paul Lallion (Grenada), October 21, 2002.
Report on the Merits No. 56/02, Petition No. 12.158 – Benedict Jacob (Grenada), October 21, 2002.
Report on the Merits No. 58/02, Petition No. 12.275– Denton Aitken (Jamaica), October 21, 2002.
Report on the Merits No. 76/02, Case No. 12.347 – Dave Sewell (Jamaica), December 27, 2002.
Report on the Merits No. 77/02, Petition No. 11.506 – Waldemar Geronimo Pinhero and Jose Victor dos Santos (Paraguay), December 27, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 47/01, Case No. 12.028 – Donnason Knights (Grenada), April 4, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 48/01, Cases N. 12.067, 12.068 and 12.086– Michael Edwards, Omar Hall, Brian Schroeter and Jeronimo Bowing (Bahamas), April 4, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 49/01, Case No. 11.826– Leroy Lamey, Kevin Mykoo, Milton Montique and Dalton Daley (Jamaica), April 4, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 50/01, Case No. 12.069 – Damion Thomas (Jamaica), April 4, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 51/01, Case No. 9903 – Rafael Ferrer-Mazorra and others (United States of America), April 4, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 53/01, Case No. 11.565 – Ana, Beatriz and Celia Gonzalez Perez (Mexico), April 4, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 66/01, Case No. 11.992 – Dayra Maria Levoyer Jimenez (Ecuador), June 14, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 127/01, Case No. 11.381 – Joseph Thomas (Jamaica), December 3, 2001.
Report on the Merits No. 34/00, Case No. 11.291 – Carandiru (Brasil), April 13, 2000.
Report on the Merits No. 38/00, Case No. 11.743 – Rudolph Baptiste (Grenada), April 13, 2000.
Report on the Merits No. 41/00, Cases No. 12.023, 12.044, 12.107, 12.126 and 12.146– Desmond McKenzie and others (Jamaica), April 13, 2000.
Report on the Merits No. 49/00, Case 11.182 – Carlos Molero Coca and others (Peru), April 13, 2000.
Report on the Merits Nº 41/99, Case No. 11.491 – Menores Detenidos (Honduras), March 10, 1999.
Report on the Merits Nº 60/99, Case No. 11.516 – Ovelario Tames (Brazil), April 13, 1999.
Report on the Merits Nº 63 /99, Case No. 11.427 – Victor Rosario Congo (Ecuador), April 13, 1999.
Report on the Merits Nº 64/99, Case No. 11.778 – Ruth del Rosario Garces Valladares (Ecuador), April 13, 1999.
Report on the Merits Nº 1/97, Case No. 10.258 – Manuel Garcia Franco (Ecuador), March 12, 1997.
Report on the Merits Nº 2/97, Cases No. 11.205, 11.236, 11.238, 11.242, 11.243, 11.244, 11.247, 11.248, 11.249, 11.251, 11.254, 11.255, 11.257, 11.258, 11.261, 11.263, 11.305, 11.320, 11.326, 11.330, 11.499 y 11.504 – Jorge Luis Bronstein and others (Argentina), March 11, 1997.
Report on the Merits Nº 55/97, Case No. 11.137 – Juan Carlos Abella (Argetina), November 18, 1997.
Report on the Merits No. 12/96, Case No. 11.245 – Jorge Jimenez (Argentina), March 1, 1996.
Report on the Merits No. 31/96, Case No. 10.526 – Diana Ortiz (Guatemala), October 16, 1996.
Report on the Merits Nº 35/96, Case No. 10.832 – Luis Lizardo Cabrera (Dominican Republic), February 19, 1998.
Report on the Merits No. 38/96, Case No. 10.506 – X and Y (Argentina), October 15, 1996.
Report on the Admissibility and Merits No. 5/94, Case No. 10.574 – Elvis Gustavo Lovato Rivera (El Salvador), February 1, 1994.
Report on the Admissibility and Merits No. 7/94, Case No. 10.911 – Flor de Maria Hernandez Rivas (El Salvador), February 1, 1994.
Report on the Merits No. 9/94, Case No. 11.105 – Jean Emile Estimable and others (Haiti), February 1, 1994.
Report on the Merits No. 25/94, Case No. 10.508 – Roberto Lissandri and Dino Rossi (Guatemala), September 22, 1994.
Report on the Admissibility and Merits No. 27/94, Case No. 11.084 – Jaime Salinas Sedo (Peru), November 30, 1994.

Friendly Settlement Report No. 164/10, Caso 12.623 - Luis Rey García Villagrán (México), 1 de noviembre de 2010.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 16/10, Petición 11.796 - Mario Humberto Gómez Yardez (Argentina), 16 de marzo de 2010.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 24/09, Case No. 11.822 – Reyes Penagos Martinez et all (Mexico), March 20, 2009.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 44/06, Petition No. 12.205 – Jose Rene Castro Galarza (Ecuador), March 15, 2006.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 45/06, Petition No. 12.207 – Lizandro Ramiro Montero (Ecuador), March 15, 2006.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 110/06, Case No. 12.555 – Sebastian Echaniz Alcorta and Juan Victor Galarza Mendiola (Venezuela), October 21, 2006.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 91/03, Case No. 11.804 – Angel Greco (Argentina), October 22, 2003.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 64/03, Case No. 12.188 – Joffre Jose Valencia Mero, Priscila Zoreida Valencia Sanchez, Rocio Valencia Sanchez (Ecuador), October 10, 2003.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 66/03, Case No. 11.312 – Emilio Tec Pop (Guatemala), October 10, 2003.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 32/02, Petition No. 11.715 – Juan Manuel Contreras San Martin et all (Chile), March 12, 2002.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 19/01, Case No. 11.478 – Climaco Cuellar et all (Ecuador), February 20, 2001.
Friendly Settlement Report No. 1/93, Cases No. 10.288, 10.310, 10.436, 10.496, 10.631 y 10.771 – Miguel Vaca Narvajal et al (Argentina), March 3, 1993.

César Alberto Mendoza et al. - Perpetual Imprisonment and confinement of adolescents
Case 12.651, Argentina, June 17, 2011
Rafael Arturo Pacheco Teruel y Otros; Muertes por incendio en el Centro Penal de San Pedro Sula
Case 12.680, Honduras, March 11, 2011
Raúl José Díaz Peña
Case 12.703, Venezuela, November 12, 2010

Pedro Miguel Vera Vera et al
Case 11.535, Ecuador, February 24, 2010
Jesús Tranquilino Vélez Loor
Case 12.581, Panama, October 8, 2009
Lysias Fleury y su familia
Caso 12.549, Haiti, August 5, 2009
Teodoro Cabrera García e Rodolfo Montiel Flores
Case 12.449, Mexico, June 24, 2009
Oscar Barreto Leiva
Case 11.663, Venezuela, October 31, 2008
Francisco Usón Ramírez
Case 12.554, Venezuela, July 25, 2008
Juan Carlos Bayarri (available only in Spanish)
Case 11.280, Argentina, July 16, 2007
Yvon Neptune
Case 12.514, Haiti, December 14, 2006
French version also available
Lennox Boyce, Jeffrey Joseph, Fredrick Benjamin Atkins and Michael Huggins (Boyce et al.)
Case 12.480, Barbados, December 14, 2006
Juan Carlos Chaparro and Freddy Hernán Lapo
Case 12.091, Ecuador, June 23, 2006
Juan Francisco Bueno Alves
Case 12.425, Argentina, March 31, 2006
Only available in Spanish.
Víctor Jesús Montero Aranguren y otros (Retén de Catia)
Case 11.699, Venezuela, February 24, 2005
Available only in Spanish
Marco Antonio Servellón y otros (Cuatro Puntos Cardinales)
Caso 12.331, Honduras, February 2, 2005
Available only in Spanish
Damiao Ximenes Lopes
Case 12.237, Brazil, October 1, 2004
Ronald Ernesto Raxcacó Reyes
Case 12.402, Guatemala, September 18, 2004
Hugo Juárez Cruzatt and Others (Centro Penal Miguel Castro Castro)
Case 11.015, Peru, September 9, 2004
Wilson García Asto y Urcesino Ramírez Rojas
Case 12.413, Peru, June 22, 2004
Wilson Gutiérrez Soler
Case 12.291, Colombia, March 26, 2004

Report No. 165/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 444/99 – Edilberto Nuñoz Coronell (or Coronel); Mauricio Alfonso Mejía Lesmes; Rogelio Martínez Ramírez; Eulogio Iguaran Epieyu; Jimmy Nagles Marquez; and Octavio Toro Salazar (Barbados), November 1, 2010.
Report No. 129/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 4327/02 – Persons Deprived of Liberty in the Central Penitentiary of Parana (Brazil), October 23, 2010.
Report No. 92/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 1122-03 – José Quirino Alves Júnior (Brazil), July 15, 2010.
Report No. 36/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 11.718 – Anthony Johnson (Trinidad y Tobago), March 16, 2010.
Report No. 20/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 139-00 – Daniel Ricardo Bellini (Argentina), March 16, 2010. (Available only in Spanish)
Report No. 21/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 1003-03 – Juan Carlos Ruiz Diaz (Argentina), March 16, 2010. (Available only in Spanish)
Report No. 22/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 695-01 – Leonardo Cristian Rocha (Argentina), March 16, 2010. (Available only in Spanish)
Report Nº 46/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 456-10 – Jose Geraldo Araujo (Brasil), March 17, 2010.
Report Nº 97/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 12.136 – Segismundo Gerardo Porras Jimenez (Costa Rica), June 15, 2010.
Report Nº 59/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 11.542 – Francisco Llaguno Cobos (Ecuador), March 24, 2010.
Report Nº 25/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 461-01 – Lucien Gervais (Haiti), March 16, 2010.
Report Nº 28/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 897-03 – Canute Cummingham (Jamaica), March 16, 2010.
Report N° 33/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 11.806 – Demetrio Limonier Chavez Penaherrera (Peru), March 16, 2010.
Report N° 60/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 10.741 – Luis Efrain Pena Solar (Peru), March 24, 2010.
Report No. 104/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 11.177 – Juan Manuel Castro (Peru), July 15, 2010.
Report Nº 34/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 1118-04 – Luis Miguel Sanchez Aldana (Suriname), March 16, 2010.
Report Nº 35/10, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 12.187 – Peter Isaac (Trinidad and Tobago), March 16, 2010.
Report No. 46/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 12.211 – Carlos Andres Correa (Argentina), March 27, 2009.
Report No. 122/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 6-03 – Maria Dolores Gomez (Argentina), November 12, 2009.
Report No. 123/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 872-03 – Juan Antonio Diaz Diaz (Chile), November 12, 2009.
Report No. 124/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 4616-02 – Epifanio Escalona (Chile), November 12, 2009.
Report No. 127/09, Decision to Archive, Petition 10.965 – Juan Pablo Lemus Silva (Guatemala), November 12, 2009.
Report No. 50/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 546-03 – Carlos Nibardo Jasso (Mexico), March 27, 2009.
Report No. 51/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 484-03 – Oscar Davila Lopez (Mexico), March 27, 2009.
Report No. 52/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 216-04 – Luis Castillo Sepulveda (Mexico), March 27, 2009.
Report No. 130/09, Decision to Archive, Petition No. 11.875 – Luis Gonzaga Lara y Magencio A. Zeferino (Mexico), November 12, 2009.